But first, I must add that I was a bit baffled by the inclusion of Six-Sigma in the whole ‘ROI’ question since true Six-Sigma projects always look to answer “How much will this save?”, or “How much will this reduce our scrap costs by?” … clearly ROI centric questions.
Lean, on the other hand, is a different story. A good lean program will yield thousands of small ideas. In fact, one of the main reasons ideas are seldom documented beyond the Kaizen Card, is that a program administrator would be immediately overwhelmed by having to input each idea into a database or spreadsheet. A further reason is that fact that these databases are accessible by few (usually management), and thus the true benefit of documenting the data beyond having a catalog of ideas for reporting purposes at times does not justify the effort.
Enter idea management software: Web based idea management software solves this problem. Instead of one person documenting the ideas, every member of the organization is responsible for recording their ideas. The system catalogs and helps administrators to manage the workflow and even assign ‘rewards’. But the greatest benefit is the fact that these ideas are searchable by everyone. Users can look to see if solutions have been found for similar problems, and that in itself helps propagate solutions across the organization (Yokoten).
Once ideas reside in the database, it is easy to calculate the ROI from actual cost figures or even reductions in processing time (Yes, although process time savings are not immediately visible, they become tangible once lines are re-balanced.)
I also found this article in the Chartered Management Institute website referencing the same study by AlixPartners LP. Interesting how simple it is to create your baseline in order to capture your ROI... however, I go back to my scenario of a good Lean process... how do you document this for thousands of ideas?
ReplyDeleteGood Ideas management software adds utilities like ideas voting and grouping of similar suggestions to the mix, allowing greater prioritization to the database of ideas.
ReplyDeleteWhilst commonly, software documents ideas via manual input, there are also solutions which can garner suggestions by crawling the social web and returning feedback from user discussions. With the (final) maturation of voice recognition technology over the past couple of years, i imagine it wont be long before a team sessions can be auto dictated into the database and the barrier of manual submission is removed entirely.
Thanks for sharing!
Luke W
Community Manager
OneDesk